×
×
≡Menu
Search

Negligence and personal injury cases

Home
Blog
Premises Liability
Negligence and personal injury cases

Negligence and personal injury cases

The concept of res ipsa loquitur in personal injury cases in Illinois and across the nation means that the plaintiff can presume that the defendant was negligent without direct proof, using only circumstantial evidence. In these cases, the defendant instead bears the burden of showing that they did not act negligently.

Even so, the courts do not assume negligence on the part of a property owner after an accident. The plaintiff generally needs to show that negligence caused the injury. If the plaintiff does not have direct evidence, they can use circumstantial evidence in some situations. Circumstantial evidence simply means that a jury or rational person could infer negligence as the logical conclusion in a case based on general knowledge and experience.

The original case of res ipsa loquitur, which means ‘the thing speaks for itself,” is based on an incident when a barrel of flour fell on a plaintiff who was walking near a warehouse and was injured as a result. The courts determined that a rational person could assume that someone acted negligently by failing to close or block the window or store the barrel, resulting in the fall. Over time, the applications in each situation have developed as the courts have ruled on related cases. Each state has slightly different rules regarding a negligent property owner, but they generally follow a formula to determine if res ipsa exists. Courts must show that the individual in question was negligent, resulting in the incident, that the plaintiff or a third party did not cause the accident and that the defendant failed to exercise their duty to prevent the incident.

In some cases, a rational person and the jury can easily see that the defendant acted negligently when they apply the principles of res ipsa. A personal injury lawyer might argue that the factors for res ipsa exist in a case.

SHARE THIS POST
facebooktwittergoogle

Categories

Archives

Reviews

Providing Legal
Solutions In An
Equitable &
Cost-Effective Manner

Related Articles

Single Blog Image
26Oct

As if the injuries, medical bills, missed work, and constant hassle after your car accident weren't enough, you now have another problem to deal with: the driver who hit you…

Single Blog Image
19Oct

Maybe you’re already thinking about where life could take you after your divorce. You might have a job opportunity in another city, family you want to be closer to, or…

Single Blog Image
12Oct

A truck tire blowout can happen in seconds, but the damage it leaves behind can last for years. If you were injured in a crash caused by a blown truck…

Your privacy choices

Privacy preferences

Use this control to opt out of sale or sharing of personal information for cross-context behavioral advertising. On this website, opting out also stops optional analytics and advertising tracking in this browser. See our privacy statement.

Turn this off and save your choice to stop optional tracking. Contact forms and direct scheduling links remain available.